PROMESA

• The Bottom Line: PROMESA is a U.S. federal law that created a bankruptcy-like process for American territories, offering a complex but potentially lucrative playground for distressed debt investors who can navigate chaos with a massive margin_of_safety.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: A legal framework that allows a U.S. territory, like Puerto Rico, to restructure its unpayable debts under federal court supervision, much like a corporation does under Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
• Why it matters: It transforms government bonds, once considered ultra-safe, into high-risk, high-reward assets during a crisis. It provides a rulebook for a messy situation, which a value investor can study to find deeply mispriced opportunities.
• How to use it: By understanding its mechanisms, an investor can analyze the potential recovery value of a territory's defaulted bonds and determine if they are trading at a deep enough discount to be a worthwhile, albeit risky, investment.

Imagine a friend, let's call him Sam, who has run into serious financial trouble. He has mortgages, car loans, and credit card bills piling up, and his income can't cover the payments. For an individual, the solution is often personal bankruptcy—a legal process to either wipe the slate clean or create a manageable repayment plan. A corporation in the same boat can file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, allowing it to stay in business while it renegotiates its debts with lenders. But what happens when the one in trouble isn't a person or a company, but a government? Specifically, a U.S. territory like Puerto Rico, which in the mid-2010s was drowning in over $70 billion of debt it could not possibly repay. Unlike U.S. states, territories didn't have a clear legal path to declare bankruptcy. It was a chaotic free-for-all, with creditors suing and the government teetering on the brink of total collapse. Enter PROMESA. Signed into law in 2016, the Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act (the Spanish word “promesa” also means “promise”) is essentially a custom-built Chapter 11 for U.S. territories. It’s a federal law that hits the pause button on the chaos and creates an orderly, court-supervised process for a government to restructure its finances. At its heart, PROMESA did two critical things: 1. It created an oversight board: A powerful, federally appointed body—officially the Financial Oversight and Management Board (FOMB), but widely known in Puerto Rico as “La Junta“—was put in charge. Think of them as the tough, experienced financial advisors Sam’s family might hire to take away his credit cards, create a strict budget, and negotiate with his lenders. La Junta has the final say on Puerto Rico’s budgets and fiscal plans. 2. It provided a restructuring tool: It gives the territory the legal power to bring all its creditors to the negotiating table and force them to accept a “haircut”—a reduction in what they are owed. This process, known as Title III, is the core of the bankruptcy-like proceeding. In short, PROMESA is the rulebook for a game no one wanted to play: the restructuring of a government's debt. It turns an impossible financial situation into a complex, but manageable, legal and financial puzzle.

“The best opportunities are often found in situations where others are either unable or unwilling to look.” - Seth Klarman ¹⁾

For the average stock-picker, a law about territorial debt might seem obscure. But for a value investor, particularly one focused on distressed situations, PROMESA is a fascinating case study in core principles. It matters because it creates an environment where market panic and complexity can lead to profound mispricing.

• Panic Creates Opportunity: When Puerto Rico's crisis reached its peak, the market panicked. Investors who had bought municipal bonds thinking they were second only to U.S. Treasuries in safety rushed for the exits, selling their bonds for 20, 30, or 40 cents on the dollar. A value investor, guided by the wisdom of Benjamin Graham, sees this panic not as a reason to flee, but as a reason to start digging. The central question becomes: “What is the rational, underlying value here, separate from the fear?”
• Complexity is a Moat: The PROMESA process is incredibly complex. It involves different classes of bonds with competing legal claims, political maneuvering in both San Juan and Washington D.C., and years of court battles. This complexity scares away most investors. A value investor, however, understands that a situation that is hard to understand is often inefficiently priced. If you are willing to do the hard work—to read the legal documents, understand the territorial economy, and follow the court proceedings—you can develop an informational edge. This is a classic application of building your circle_of_competence in a niche area.
• The Search for Intrinsic Value in Debt: A value investor knows that the price of an asset and its underlying value are two different things. For a bond in a PROMESA restructuring, its price is what it trades for on the market (e.g., 25 cents on the dollar). Its intrinsic value is the estimated recovery value—what you will likely receive in new bonds and/or cash after the restructuring is complete. The value investor's job is to calculate a conservative estimate of that recovery value. PROMESA provides the legal framework that makes this calculation possible, even if it's difficult.
• The Ultimate Test of Margin of Safety: This is the most critical link. Investing in a PROMESA situation is inherently risky. Your analysis could be wrong, the political winds could shift, or the economic recovery could falter. Therefore, you must demand a massive margin of safety. If your careful analysis suggests a bond’s recovery value is 60 cents on the dollar, you don't buy it at 55 cents. A true value investor might wait until the price falls to 30 cents or less. This discount is your buffer against bad luck, bad timing, and bad analysis. It’s the difference between prudent investing and reckless speculation.

PROMESA, therefore, isn't just a law; it's a real-world laboratory for applying the most rigorous principles of value investing to the chaotic world of government finance.

You don't “calculate” PROMESA, but you must understand its mechanisms to analyze an investment. It's a process, not a formula.

A distressed-debt investor would analyze the process by breaking it down into these key stages and components:

1. 1. The Oversight Board (FOMB) Takes Control: The first step is the assertion of federal authority. The FOMB is created and given sweeping powers to approve fiscal plans, certify budgets, and represent the territory in restructuring talks. For an investor, the FOMB's public statements, approved budgets, and economic projections are essential reading. They signal how much the board believes the territory can sustainably pay its creditors.
2. 2. The “Stay” on Litigation: PROMESA imposes an automatic stay, preventing creditors from suing the territory to collect their debts. This is a critical “time out.” It stops a chaotic race to the courthouse and forces all parties into the structured process defined by the law. This stability allows for a more rational negotiation.
3. 3. The Restructuring (Title III): This is the main event. The territory, through the FOMB, files for Title III protection, which is functionally a court-supervised bankruptcy. Here's where the key battles are fought:
   • Classifying Claims: The court and creditors argue over which bonds have priority. Are the constitutionally-guaranteed General Obligation (GO) bonds superior to the sales-tax-backed COFINA bonds? The answer to this question dramatically impacts the recovery value of each bond type.
   • Negotiating the “Plan of Adjustment”: This is the formal restructuring plan. It details exactly how each class of creditor will be treated—how deep the “haircut” will be, and what the terms of any new bonds (principal, interest rate, maturity) will be.
   • Voting and “Cramdown”: Creditors vote on the plan. Critically, PROMESA allows for a “cramdown,” where a plan can be approved by the court even if some classes of creditors vote against it, as long as the plan is deemed fair and equitable.
4. 4. The Emergence: If the Plan of Adjustment is confirmed by the court, the territory “emerges” from the Title III process. The old, defaulted bonds are cancelled and creditors receive their new, restructured bonds and/or cash as outlined in the plan. These new bonds are designed to be sustainable based on the FOMB-approved fiscal plans.

For an investor, every step of this process is a piece of the puzzle.

• “High” vs. “Low” Priority: The central analytical task is determining where a specific bond sits in the legal pecking order. A bond with a strong legal claim to a dedicated revenue stream (like a special tax) is likely to have a higher recovery value than a bond with a weaker, more general claim. The market will price these bonds differently, and the investor's job is to see if the market's pricing accurately reflects the legal realities.
• The Exit Financing: The new bonds issued upon emergence are the ultimate prize. An investor must analyze their terms. A new bond paying 5% interest is far more valuable than one paying 2%. The viability of these new bonds is the foundation of the entire investment thesis.
• Pitfalls: The biggest trap is underestimating the political element. Public pensions, government services, and bondholders are all competing for a slice of a much smaller economic pie. Political pressure can lead to outcomes that defy pure legal or financial logic. A spreadsheet can't model a riot or a change in administration in Washington.

Let's walk through a simplified, hypothetical scenario based on the Puerto Rico crisis. Imagine it's late 2017. PROMESA is in full swing, and Puerto Rico is under Title III protection. The market is in turmoil.

• The Assets: There are two main (fictionalized for simplicity) types of bonds:
  • “PR-GO” Bonds: General Obligation bonds, backed by the “full faith and credit” of the government. They are trading at 20 cents on the dollar.
  • “PR-RUM” Bonds: Revenue bonds, backed specifically by a tax on the island's famous rum exports. They are trading at 45 cents on the dollar.
• The Investor: Valerie, a value investor specializing in distressed debt, decides to investigate. She ignores the panicked headlines and focuses on the process.
• Valerie's Analysis:

1. Read the Documents: She spends weeks reading PROMESA itself, the FOMB's fiscal plans, and the legal arguments filed by creditors for both GO and RUM bonds.

  2.  **Estimate Sustainable Debt:** She analyzes the FOMB's economic projections and concludes Puerto Rico can sustainably support a total debt load that would equate to an average recovery of about 55 cents on the dollar across all debt classes.
  3.  **Analyze Legal Claims:** Her legal analysis suggests the RUM bonds have a very strong, "ring-fenced" claim to the rum tax revenue. She believes they will get superior treatment. She estimates their recovery value will be high, perhaps **75 cents on the dollar**.
  4.  The GO bonds, however, are a general claim on a government that must also pay for pensions, schools, and police. She predicts they will face a much larger haircut. She estimates their recovery value at only **40 cents on the dollar**.
*   **The Investment Decision & Margin of Safety:**

^ Bond Type ^ Market Price ^ Valerie's Estimated Recovery ^ Margin of Safety ^ Decision ^

Valerie sees a significant margin of safety in both. The GO bonds, while riskier and with a lower expected recovery, are trading at such a steep discount that they offer a higher margin of safety. She decides to invest in both, allocating more to the GO bonds because of the superior discount to her estimated intrinsic value.

• The Outcome (Years Later): The court battle is long and arduous. In 2022, a final Plan of Adjustment is approved.
  • The PR-RUM bonds, with their strong legal claim, indeed receive favorable treatment: a recovery package of new bonds worth 70 cents on the dollar.
  • The PR-GO bonds get a worse deal than the RUM bonds, but a better deal than many feared: a package worth 50 cents on the dollar.

Valerie's investment was a success. She more than doubled her money on the GO bonds (buying at 20, recovering 50) and made a solid 55% return on the RUM bonds (buying at 45, recovering 70). Her success wasn't luck. It came from ignoring the market's fear, doing the hard analytical work, and, most importantly, demanding a price that provided a substantial margin of safety in case her estimates were off.

• Creates Order from Chaos: For an investor, PROMESA's greatest strength is that it provides a legal, semi-predictable process. It replaces anarchy with a rulebook, which allows for rational analysis of outcomes.
• Unearths Deep Value: The combination of sovereign debt crisis, complexity, and market panic is a perfect storm for creating deep value opportunities where assets trade for a fraction of their likely recovery value.
• Enforces Fiscal Discipline: The FOMB's role in forcing a government to live within its means can improve the territory's long-term economic health, making the new, restructured bonds a potentially sound investment for the future.

• Extreme Complexity: This is not a field for amateurs. It requires a deep understanding of bankruptcy law, municipal finance, and political science. Misinterpreting a single clause in a bond indenture can lead to a total loss. This is far outside the average investor's circle_of_competence.
• Political and Social Risk: The outcome is not determined in a vacuum. It is heavily influenced by politicians, public sentiment, and social needs (like funding pensions and essential services). These factors are unpredictable and can override purely legal arguments.
• Protracted Timelines: These restructurings can take many years to resolve. Capital is tied up for long periods with no guarantee of the outcome. The investor must have extreme patience and a long-term time horizon.
• “Value Trap” Potential: An investor might correctly analyze the legal standing of a bond but overestimate the government's ability or willingness to pay. If the underlying economy doesn't recover, even a restructured bond can default again in the future.

• distressed_investing
• margin_of_safety
• circle_of_competence
• chapter_11_bankruptcy
• municipal_bonds
• intrinsic_value
• risk_management