Private Debt

• The Bottom Line: Private debt is simply lending money to companies outside of the public stock and bond markets, offering potentially higher returns in exchange for lower liquidity and greater complexity.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: Direct loans from specialized investment funds and institutions to private businesses, bypassing traditional banks and public markets.
• Why it matters: It represents a massive, growing asset class that can offer diversification and attractive income, but it demands a deep understanding of credit_risk and business fundamentals.
• How to use it: For most individual investors, access is indirect through publicly traded vehicles like Business Development Companies (BDCs) or specialized funds.

Imagine your town has two businesses. One is a massive, publicly-traded corporation like Coca-Cola. When Coca-Cola needs to borrow billions of dollars, it can sell bonds on the public market. Anyone with a brokerage account can buy a Coca-Cola bond, and these bonds are traded every day. This is public debt. The other business is “Steady Eddy's Premium Hardware,” a successful, family-owned regional chain. It’s a great business with consistent profits, but it’s not a global giant. Steady Eddy wants to borrow $30 million to open five new stores. He can't sell bonds on the public market—it's too complex and expensive for a business his size. His local bank, meanwhile, has become very conservative since the 2008 financial crisis and is only willing to lend him half of what he needs. Where does Steady Eddy turn? He turns to the private debt market. Private debt, at its core, is a vast and vital lending world that operates in the shadows of the public markets. It consists of specialized investment funds—often called “private credit” funds—that raise capital from institutions (like pension funds and insurance companies) and wealthy individuals. They then act like a new generation of sophisticated banks, lending this capital directly to companies like Steady Eddy's. These are not stock-market transactions. Each loan is a private, negotiated deal between one lender and one borrower. The terms—the interest rate, the repayment schedule, the rules the borrower must follow (called covenants)—are all customized. Because these loans are not publicly traded, they are illiquid. The lender can't just click a button and sell the loan to someone else. They are committed to holding it, often for years, until it's repaid. To compensate for this lack of liquidity and the inherent risk of lending to smaller companies, private debt lenders demand, and usually receive, higher interest rates than they would on comparable public bonds.

“The first rule of investment is don't lose. And the second rule of investment is don't forget the first rule. And that's all the rules there are.” - Warren Buffett. This principle is the very soul of a good private debt investor, whose primary job is the careful assessment of risk to ensure the return of capital before considering the return on capital.

This vast market has exploded in size over the last decade, becoming a critical engine of growth for the thousands of medium-sized businesses that are the backbone of the economy.

At first glance, “private debt” might sound like a playground for Wall Street insiders, far removed from the core tenets of value investing. But if you look under the hood, you’ll find that the discipline of a great private debt manager is almost a perfect reflection of value investing principles. It's about fundamental analysis, not market speculation. 1. The Ultimate “Bottom-Up” Business Analysis: A private debt investor cannot simply look at a stock chart or a quarterly earnings headline. To make a loan, they must become a temporary expert in the borrower's business. They conduct intense due_diligence, interviewing management, analyzing financial statements for years back, understanding the company's competitive position, and modeling its future cash_flow. They are not buying a ticker symbol; they are lending to a living, breathing business. This is the exact same “know the business” approach that Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett have championed for decades. 2. A Built-in Margin of Safety: The concept of a margin of safety is value investing's north star. In private debt, this isn't just a theoretical buffer in a stock's price; it's contractually built into the loan itself in several layers:

• Seniority: Debt gets paid before equity. In the capital_structure, a private lender is typically first or near the front of the line to get their money back if the business runs into trouble. Stockholders are last.
• Collateral: Loans are often secured by the company's assets (inventory, equipment, real estate). If the borrower defaults, the lender can seize and sell these assets to recover their principal.
• Covenants: These are rules and financial performance metrics the borrower must maintain. For example, a covenant might require the company to keep its total debt below a certain multiple of its earnings. If the business starts to perform poorly and breaches a covenant, the lender gets an early warning signal and the right to step in and protect their investment, long before the company goes bankrupt.
• Interest Rate Premium: The higher yield itself provides a cushion against potential losses.

3. The Reward for Patience and Illiquidity: Value investors are temperamentally suited for the long term. They understand that market volatility is often just noise. Private debt forces this discipline. Because the loans are illiquid, investors cannot panic-sell during a market downturn. Their reward for this forced patience and for locking up their capital is the “illiquidity premium”—a higher potential return than what's available in the more flighty public markets. They are paid to ignore the market's manic-depressive mood swings. 4. The Circle of Competence is Paramount: A value investor knows not to stray outside their circle of competence. This is brutally enforced in private debt. You cannot be a tourist. A successful lender needs deep expertise in credit analysis, legal documentation, and specific industry dynamics. For the individual investor, this means your circle of competence isn't about picking the individual loans, but about having the ability to pick a skilled, trustworthy, and disciplined manager to do it for you.

For an individual, directly lending millions to a private company is not feasible. The practical application of this concept involves investing through vehicles that pool investor capital and are managed by professionals.

1. 1. Honest Self-Assessment: Before anything else, understand that this is not a core holding like an S&P 500 index fund. Ask yourself:
   • Do I need this money in the next 5-10 years? If so, the illiquidity of most private debt vehicles makes them unsuitable.
   • Do I have a high tolerance for risk and complexity? You are taking on credit risk and manager risk.
   • Am I looking for income or growth? Private debt is primarily an income-generating asset class.
   • ¹⁾
2. 2. Choose Your Vehicle: Your options for accessing this market vary widely in terms of accessibility, liquidity, and complexity.
   • Business Development Companies (BDCs): This is the most common route for individual investors. BDCs are companies that are publicly traded on stock exchanges (like the NYSE or Nasdaq). Their entire business model is to invest in the debt (and sometimes equity) of private, middle-market American companies. You can buy and sell shares of a BDC just like any other stock. They are required by law to pay out at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends, often resulting in high dividend yields.
   • Closed-End Funds (CEFs): Some CEFs focus on private credit or a mix of public and private debt instruments. Like BDCs, they trade on an exchange and can offer high income distributions.
   • Private Funds (for Accredited Investors): These are the traditional private equity-style funds with long lock-up periods (often 7-10 years), high investment minimums, and a “2 and 20” fee structure (a 2% annual management fee and 20% of profits). This is the least liquid and least accessible option.
3. 3. Perform Due Diligence on the Manager: When you invest in a BDC or a fund, you are not just buying a portfolio of loans; you are hiring a management team. This is the most critical step. Your focus should be on:
   • Underwriting Philosophy: Read their investor presentations and annual reports. Do they prioritize safety or chase the highest yields? Are they focused on specific industries where they have an edge? A conservative, value-oriented approach is what you want to see.
   • Track Record: How has their portfolio performed through different economic cycles, especially during downturns like 2008 or 2020? Look at their history of loan defaults and losses.
   • Fee Structure: Fees are a direct drag on your return. Understand the management fees and any incentive fees. For BDCs, these are detailed in their public filings. High fees can turn a good investment into a mediocre one.
   • Alignment of Interests: Does management own a significant amount of stock in their own BDC? This is a strong sign that their interests are aligned with yours.

When analyzing a BDC or a similar vehicle, you are acting as a value investor evaluating a financial company. Key things to look for include:

• Net Asset Value (NAV): This is the underlying value of the BDC's loan portfolio on a per-share basis. You should look for BDCs trading at or below their NAV, which can provide a margin_of_safety. A consistent history of growing NAV is a sign of a well-managed portfolio.
• Portfolio Quality: Look at the diversification. How many different companies are in the portfolio? Is it concentrated in a risky sector like consumer retail? What percentage of loans are “first-lien,” meaning they have the highest priority for repayment? Higher first-lien exposure is more conservative.
• Non-Accruals: This is the percentage of loans in the portfolio that have stopped making interest payments. It's a direct measure of credit problems. A low and stable non-accrual rate is a sign of disciplined underwriting.

Let's put this all together. The Borrower: “Healthy Harvest Organics,” a private company with $100 million in annual revenue, wants to acquire a smaller competitor for $40 million. Their bank will only finance half of the deal. The Lender: “Bedrock Capital BDC,” a publicly traded Business Development Company. Bedrock's investment team performs deep due diligence on Healthy Harvest. They love the company's stable customer base, strong management team, and consistent cash flow. The Deal: Bedrock agrees to lend Healthy Harvest the remaining $20 million. The loan is structured with multiple layers of protection for Bedrock and its shareholders:

• Interest Rate: A floating rate of SOFR ²⁾ + 7.0%. If the benchmark rate is 5%, Healthy Harvest pays 12% interest. This high rate compensates Bedrock for the risk.
• Seniority: The loan is “first-lien, senior-secured,” meaning Bedrock is at the very front of the line to be repaid and the loan is backed by all the assets of Healthy Harvest.
• Covenants: Healthy Harvest must maintain a Debt-to-EBITDA ratio below 4.0x and is restricted from paying large dividends to its private equity owners without Bedrock's permission.

The Individual Investor: You, a value investor named Susan, are looking for a high-income investment to diversify your portfolio of stocks. You cannot lend directly to Healthy Harvest. However, you can analyze and buy shares in Bedrock Capital BDC. You research Bedrock and find that:

1. It trades at 95% of its Net Asset Value (a 5% discount).
2. Its management team has a 15-year track record with below-average default rates.
3. 85% of its portfolio is in conservative first-lien loans.
4. It pays a 9.5% dividend yield, which is fully covered by its investment income.

By buying shares in Bedrock, Susan gains indirect exposure to a diversified portfolio of carefully underwritten loans to dozens of companies just like Healthy Harvest, all while benefiting from the professional management and risk controls of the Bedrock team.

• Attractive Yields: Private debt typically offers higher interest rates (yields) than public corporate bonds or government bonds, providing a potent source of income.
• Diversification: The performance of private debt is often driven by the underlying health of the borrowing companies rather than public market sentiment. This can provide valuable diversification away from the volatility of the stock market.
• Stronger Investor Protections: Through covenants and seniority in the capital_structure, lenders have more power to protect their capital compared to public bondholders or stockholders.
• Illiquidity Premium: Investors are theoretically compensated with higher long-term returns for their inability to sell the investment on a whim.

• Illiquidity: This is the flip side of the premium. Your capital is locked in. For BDCs and CEFs, while the shares are liquid, their prices can be volatile and may trade at significant discounts to their underlying value, especially during market panics.
• Credit Risk: The primary risk is that the borrowing companies fail to pay back their loans. This risk increases significantly during an economic recession. A poorly managed portfolio can suffer substantial losses.
• Complexity and Lack of Transparency: Valuing a portfolio of private loans is more art than science, as there are no daily market prices. This can make it difficult to assess the true value and risk of a fund or BDC at any given moment.
• High Fees: Management and performance fees can be substantial, especially in private funds. These fees eat directly into investor returns and must be carefully evaluated.

• business_development_company
• margin_of_safety
• circle_of_competence
• credit_risk
• due_diligence
• capital_structure
• interest_rates