Listed Investment Companies (LICs)

• The Bottom Line: A Listed Investment Company (LIC) is a professionally managed portfolio of assets that you can buy and sell on the stock exchange just like a single share, often giving you the chance to buy a dollar's worth of investments for less than a dollar.
• Key Takeaways:
  • What it is: An LIC is a company whose primary business is investing in a portfolio of other assets (like stocks, bonds, or property). Because it has a fixed number of shares, its market price can be different from the actual value of its investments.
  • Why it matters: The potential to buy an LIC at a discount to its underlying asset value (its NTA) is a direct application of the margin_of_safety principle, which is the cornerstone of value investing.
  • How to use it: A value investor analyzes an LIC not just on its share price, but by scrutinizing its management, its investment portfolio, its fees, and, most importantly, the discount (or premium) to its NTA.

Imagine you want to own a high-quality, diversified basket of groceries. You have two main options. Option one is to go to a giant, modern supermarket like Costco. This is like an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF). The doors are always open, and the supermarket can magically create or remove shopping carts (shares) to match customer demand perfectly. The price you pay for your cart of groceries is always almost exactly equal to the value of the groceries inside. It's efficient, transparent, and follows a set shopping list (the index). Option two is to visit a charming, old-world, family-run gourmet deli. This is your Listed Investment Company (LIC). This deli has been run by the same family for decades, and the owner (the manager) has personally, and carefully, selected every single item on the shelves based on a time-tested philosophy of quality and value. Here’s the crucial difference: the deli is a public company with a fixed number of shares. Think of these as a fixed number of “ownership certificates” for the deli itself. Because the number of these ownership certificates doesn't change, their price is determined by public supply and demand on the stock market. This means the stock market price of the deli (the LIC) can be completely different from the actual value of all the cheese, wine, and cured meats inside (the LIC's investment portfolio). Sometimes, due to market pessimism, you might be able to buy an ownership certificate for the deli for $80, even though your share of the groceries inside is worth $100. This is the magic of an LIC for a value investor. At its core, an LIC is a type of closed_end_fund. It's “closed” because it raises a fixed amount of capital from investors in an initial public offering (IPO) and then trades on the stock market like any other company, such as Apple or Coca-Cola. Its full-time job is to manage that pool of capital by investing it. Unlike “open-end” funds (like ETFs and mutual funds), investors in an LIC cannot redeem their shares directly with the company for their underlying value. They must sell their shares to another investor on the open market. This structural difference creates the potential for price-value discrepancies that value investors love to find.

“The stock market is a no-called-strike game. You don't have to swing at everything—you can wait for your pitch. And the pitch I like is when I can buy a dollar's worth of assets for 40 cents.” - Warren Buffett

For a value investor, the concept of an LIC isn't just an academic curiosity; it's a direct pathway to applying the movement's most sacred principles. While others are chasing hot stocks, the value investor can often find exceptional, durable value hiding in plain sight within the structure of an LIC.

• The Ultimate Margin of Safety: Discount to NTA: This is the single most important reason LICs appeal to value investors. The Net Tangible Assets (NTA) or Net Asset Value (NAV) is the per-share market value of the LIC’s investment portfolio, minus any liabilities. When an LIC's share price trades below its NTA, it's called “trading at a discount.” Buying a well-managed LIC at a 15% discount to NTA is like buying a portfolio of blue-chip stocks and getting a 15% discount upfront. This discount is your built-in margin of safety. If the underlying stocks fall by 10%, your position is cushioned. If the discount simply “narrows” back to the NTA, you earn a profit even if the underlying portfolio goes nowhere. It's a classic “heads I win, tails I don't lose much” scenario, straight from Benjamin Graham's playbook.
• Rational, Long-Term Management: The closed-end structure of an LIC gives its manager a tremendous advantage: a stable pool of capital. In a market panic, managers of open-end funds are often forced to sell their best assets at fire-sale prices to meet a flood of redemption requests from panicked investors. The LIC manager faces no such pressure. They can be a net buyer when others are fearful, using the market's irrationality to their advantage. This structure allows them to be truly long-term investors, which aligns perfectly with the value investing temperament.
• Access to Proven Expertise: Investing in a great LIC is like hiring a full-time portfolio manager whose philosophy aligns with your own. Many of the world's most respected value investors manage or have managed closed-end funds or LICs. By buying the LIC, you are delegating the day-to-day decisions of stock selection to an expert, allowing you to benefit from their circle_of_competence and research, often in markets or sectors you may not have time to study yourself.
• A Source of Consistent, Tax-Efficient Income: Many LICs, particularly older ones with a history of holding dividend-paying stocks, have a strong track record of paying consistent and growing dividends to their shareholders. For long-term investors focused on total return and building passive income, this is a significant benefit. In some jurisdictions, like Australia, these dividends can come with tax credits ¹⁾ that make the post-tax return even more attractive.

Finding a great LIC investment is more than just spotting a big discount. A cheap price on a poorly managed portfolio is a value trap, not a bargain. A true value investor must do their homework.

1. 1. Determine the NTA and the Discount/Premium: This is your starting point. LICs are required to report their NTA regularly (often monthly) on their website or via stock exchange announcements.
   • Formula: Discount/Premium % = `((Share Price - NTA per Share) / NTA per Share) * 100`
   • A negative result is a discount; a positive result is a premium.
2. 2. Investigate the Manager and Their Philosophy: This is the most crucial qualitative step. You are not just buying a portfolio; you are partnering with a manager.
   • Who are they? What is their long-term track record? Read their annual reports and letters to shareholders for the past 5-10 years. Does their language reflect a patient, business-like approach to investing, or does it sound like a short-term market forecast?
   • Do they eat their own cooking? Check if the managers and the board of directors own a significant number of shares in the LIC themselves. This alignment of interest is a powerful indicator of shareholder-friendly management.
3. 3. Scrutinize the Portfolio: Look under the hood.
   • What does it own? Does the portfolio consist of high-quality, durable businesses you understand, or speculative, high-risk ventures?
   • Concentration: Is it a highly concentrated portfolio (e.g., top 10 holdings are 60% of assets) or broadly diversified? A concentrated portfolio can lead to higher returns but also carries more risk if the manager gets a few big bets wrong. Ensure this matches your own risk tolerance.
4. 4. Analyze the Fees: Fees are a direct and certain drag on your long-term returns.
   • Management Expense Ratio (MER): This is the total annual cost of running the LIC, expressed as a percentage of the assets. A high MER (e.g., over 1.5%) requires the manager to be exceptionally skilled just to break even with a cheaper alternative. Value investors prefer low-cost structures.
   • Performance Fees: Does the LIC charge a performance fee for beating a benchmark? Understand exactly how this is calculated. Some structures can incentivize short-term risk-taking.
5. 5. Review the Historical Discount/Premium: Is the current discount normal for this LIC, or is it an anomaly?
   • Look at a 5- or 10-year chart of the LIC's premium/discount to NTA. If it has historically traded at an average 5% discount and is now trading at a 20% discount despite the portfolio and manager remaining strong, you may have found a genuine opportunity. If it always trades at a 20% discount, there might be a persistent reason for it (e.g., high fees or poor performance).

Let's compare two hypothetical LICs: “Steady Eddies Value Trust (SEVT)“ and “Future Forward Tech Growth (FFTG)“. Both have a Net Tangible Asset (NTA) value of $10.00 per share.

A value investor would immediately be drawn to SEVT. You are paying $8.50 for $10.00 worth of solid, understandable businesses. You have a 15% margin_of_safety baked into your purchase price. The low management fee means more of the returns stay in your pocket. Conversely, an investor in FFTG is paying $12.00 for just $10.00 worth of highly speculative assets. They are paying a premium based on the hope and hype surrounding the manager and the sector. This is the opposite of a margin of safety; it's a “margin of danger.” The high fees further erode any potential returns. The value investor's choice is clear.

• Discount to NTA: The potential to buy assets for less than their market value is the primary advantage and a direct application of value investing.
• Stable Capital Base: The closed-end structure allows managers to make rational, long-term decisions without being forced to sell during market downturns.
• Potential for Income: Many LICs have a long history of providing consistent and growing dividend streams to investors.
• Managerial Alpha: A truly skilled manager can generate returns above and beyond the market index (alpha), and an LIC can be a vehicle to access that skill.

• Discounts Can Persist or Widen: A discount is not a guarantee of future returns. A “cheap” LIC can stay cheap or get even cheaper for years, especially if management performs poorly or fees are too high. This is a classic “value trap.”
• Premiums Create Risk: Paying a premium to NTA means you are relying solely on future performance to generate a return, removing any margin of safety from the price you pay.
• High Fees: Some LICs charge exorbitant management and performance fees that can consume a large portion of the investment returns over the long term. Always compare the MER to cheaper passive alternatives like ETFs.
• Manager Risk: Your investment's success is heavily dependent on the skill and integrity of the portfolio manager. If a star manager leaves or changes their strategy, the LIC's future performance can be jeopardized.

• net_tangible_assets
• margin_of_safety
• closed_end_fund
• exchange_traded_fund_etf
• management_expense_ratio_mer
• intrinsic_value
• circle_of_competence