Charge-off Rate

• The Bottom Line: The charge-off rate is the canary in the coal mine for a lending business, revealing the percentage of loans it has given up on collecting and officially written off as a loss.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: A simple percentage showing how much of a lender's loan portfolio has gone bad and been declared uncollectible during a specific period.
• Why it matters: It's a direct, unfiltered measure of a lender's underwriting discipline and the actual riskiness of its assets. Rising charge-offs are a direct hit to profitability.
• How to use it: Compare the rate over several years and against direct competitors to assess management's competence and the bank's resilience through an economic cycle.

Imagine you're a farmer who, instead of growing crops, lends out seeds to other farmers. Your business model is simple: you lend out 100 bags of seeds, and you expect to get back 105 bags after the harvest. Those extra 5 bags are your profit. Now, most of the farmers you lend to are skilled and have fertile land. They return your seeds with the agreed-upon “interest.” But inevitably, some seeds go to farmers with rocky soil or who face a local drought. They simply can't produce a harvest, and they can't pay you back. After waiting a season or two, you realize you're never getting those specific seeds back. You have to face reality and “charge them off” your books. You declare them a loss. The charge-off rate is simply the percentage of seeds you declared as a loss in that period. If you lent out an average of 1,000 bags of seeds this year and had to write off 10 bags as lost forever, your charge-off rate is 1%. In the world of banking and lending (like credit card companies or auto lenders), the “seeds” are dollars. When a bank lends money, it's making a bet that the borrower will pay it back with interest. But some borrowers lose their jobs, get sick, or make poor financial decisions. They stop paying. The journey to a charge-off usually follows a clear path:

1. Delinquency: The borrower misses a payment. The loan is now “delinquent.”
2. Default: After a set period of non-payment (e.g., 90 or 120 days), the loan is declared to be in “default.” The bank's collection efforts intensify.
3. Charge-off: After a longer period, typically 120 to 180 days of non-payment, the bank's regulators require it to stop pretending it will be paid back in the normal course of business. The bank removes the loan from its balance sheet of performing assets and recognizes the loss.

It’s crucial to understand that a charge-off is an accounting action, not a legal one. The borrower still legally owes the debt. The bank can (and often does) continue to try to collect the money or sell the bad debt to a collection agency for pennies on the dollar. Any money recovered later is called a “recovery.”

“It's only when the tide goes out that you discover who's been swimming naked.” - Warren Buffett

This famous quote is the perfect lens through which to view charge-off rates. In good economic times, almost anyone can look like a genius lender. Jobs are plentiful, and consumers have money to pay their bills. But when the economic tide goes out (a recession hits), banks that were making reckless loans (“swimming naked”) are exposed by a sudden and massive spike in their charge-off rates.

For a value investor, analyzing a lending institution isn't just about its growth or its stated profits. It's about understanding the quality and durability of those profits. The charge-off rate is a truth serum that cuts right to the heart of a lender's business quality.

• A Window into Underwriting Quality: A consistently low and stable charge-off rate is the clearest sign of a disciplined and intelligent underwriting culture. It suggests that management prioritizes making good loans over simply making more loans. This discipline is a powerful, though often hidden, economic moat. A bank that avoids bad loans in the boom years is the one that will not only survive but thrive during the bust.
• Protecting Your Margin of Safety: When you buy shares in a bank, you are buying a piece of its loan portfolio. If that portfolio is filled with risky, low-quality debt, your investment has no margin_of_safety. A value investor analyzes a bank's charge-off rate through a full economic cycle, especially its performance during the last recession. This historical data helps you estimate a “normalized” or worst-case level of losses, which is essential for calculating the bank's true intrinsic_value and ensuring you're not overpaying.
• A Red Flag for Future Earnings: A rising charge-off rate is a direct predictor of future pain. When charge-offs increase, a bank must also increase its loan loss provision—the money it sets aside from its current income to cover expected future losses. This provision is a direct expense that reduces net income. By watching the trend in charge-offs, you can often see earnings trouble coming long before it's announced in a headline.
• Evaluating Management's Character: In banking, character and incentives are paramount. Is management compensated for short-term loan growth or long-term profitability? A high or volatile charge-off rate can indicate a management team that is willing to gamble with shareholder capital to hit aggressive, short-sighted growth targets. A value investor seeks management that acts like a true owner, prioritizing the long-term health of the loan book above all else.

The formula itself is straightforward, but understanding its components is key. `Charge-off Rate = (Net Charge-offs / Average Loans Outstanding) * 100` Let's break that down:

• Net Charge-offs: This is the critical number. It's not just the total amount of loans that went bad; it's that amount minus any money the bank recovered from loans it had previously charged off.
  • `Net Charge-offs = Gross Charge-offs - Recoveries`
  • Gross Charge-offs: The total principal and interest of all loans that the bank officially deemed uncollectible during the period (e.g., a quarter or a year).
  • Recoveries: Money collected during the period on debts that had been charged off in prior periods. A high recovery rate can signal a very effective collections department.
• Average Loans Outstanding: This is the denominator. It represents the total pool of loans from which the losses occurred.
  • `Average Loans = (Loans at Beginning of Period + Loans at End of Period) / 2`
  • We use an average because the total loan amount can change significantly during a period. An average gives a more accurate representation of the asset base that generated the charge-offs.

A charge-off rate number in isolation is almost meaningless. The art is in the interpretation, which requires context.

• Context is King: Comparing Apples to Apples: You cannot compare the charge-off rate of a credit card issuer with that of a prime mortgage lender. Their business models and risk profiles are fundamentally different.

^ Lender Type ^ Typical “Good” Charge-off Rate (in a stable economy) ^

¹⁾

• The Trend is Everything: A single data point is a snapshot; the trend is the movie. A value investor's primary focus should be on the direction of the charge-off rate over several quarters and years.
  • A stable or decreasing rate in a steady economy is a sign of health and discipline.
  • A consistently rising rate, even a small one, is a significant red flag. It suggests that loans made in previous periods are starting to sour, and management's underwriting standards may be slipping.
• The Cyclical View: All lending is cyclical. Charge-off rates will naturally fall during economic expansions and rise sharply during recessions. The key question for a value investor is not if the rate will rise in a downturn, but by how much. A superior bank will see its charge-off rate rise far less than its more aggressive peers. Look at data from 2008-2009 to see how a bank truly performed under pressure.

Let's consider two hypothetical banks to illustrate the power of this metric. Bank A: Steady Savings & Loan (SSL)

• Business Model: A conservative, community-focused bank. Primarily makes well-collateralized home mortgages and loans to established local businesses. Prioritizes loan quality over rapid growth.

Bank B: Go-Go Growth Bank (GGB)

• Business Model: An aggressive national lender. Focuses on higher-risk, higher-reward areas like unsecured personal loans and subprime auto loans to fuel rapid expansion and impress Wall Street with its growth numbers.

Here are their financials in a stable economic year:

In the good times, GGB might be praised for its fast growth. Its higher charge-off rate is seen as an acceptable cost of doing business in its lucrative niche. The value investor, however, is wary. They see the low, stable 0.40% rate at SSL as a sign of deep-rooted institutional discipline. Now, a mild recession hits. Unemployment ticks up, and consumers get squeezed.

Analysis:

• SSL's charge-off rate tripled, which is a significant increase but manageable. Their conservative loan book bent, but it didn't break. They will take an earnings hit but will almost certainly remain profitable.
• GGB's charge-off rate quadrupled to an catastrophic 12.00%. The “acceptable” risk in good times has exploded into an existential threat. The massive losses will likely wipe out its earnings and potentially its shareholder equity, forcing it to raise capital at a terrible price or face failure.

This example shows how the charge-off rate, analyzed through a conservative, long-term lens, can reveal fundamental risks that a superficial focus on growth would miss.

• Objective Measure: The charge-off rate is a hard accounting number. It is less subject to the optimistic storytelling and subjective judgments that can color other metrics. It represents actual, realized losses.
• Direct Look at Asset Quality: A bank's primary asset is its loan book. The charge-off rate is arguably the best single metric for assessing the health and quality of that core asset.
• Powerful Comparative Tool: When used to compare a bank against its direct peers, it quickly highlights which institutions are more disciplined and which are taking on more risk to achieve growth.

• It's a Lagging Indicator: A charge-off is the end of a long story. The bad loan was likely made 12-36 months before it was written off. By the time the charge-off rate spikes, the poor lending decisions have already been made. Astute investors also watch earlier-stage metrics like delinquency rates to get a heads-up.
• Management Discretion Can Obscure Timing: While the decision to charge off a loan is governed by regulations, management has some leeway. A bank might delay recognizing losses by restructuring “problem” loans to make them appear current, a practice known as “extend and pretend.” This can cause charge-off rates to look artificially low for a time.
• Doesn't Show the Full Picture Alone: The charge-off rate is a vital piece of the puzzle, but only one piece. It must be analyzed alongside the allowance_for_loan_losses (is the bank saving enough for future losses?), the net_interest_margin (is it being adequately compensated for the risks it's taking?), and capital ratios.

• loan_loss_provision
• allowance_for_loan_losses
• non_performing_loans
• credit_risk
• underwriting_standards
• net_interest_margin
• margin_of_safety