Attrition

• The Bottom Line: Attrition, often called customer churn, is the silent killer of business models; for a value investor, a consistently low attrition rate is one of the most powerful and reliable indicators of a durable competitive advantage.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: Attrition is the rate at which a company loses its customers, subscribers, or employees over a specific period.
• Why it matters: It directly impacts revenue stability, profitability, and provides a clear window into the strength of a company's economic moat. High attrition is a costly problem that erodes value.
• How to use it: Analyze its trend over time and benchmark it against direct competitors to accurately gauge a company's health and the loyalty of its customer base.

Imagine you own a local coffee shop. Your goal is to fill a large bucket with water, where the water represents your profits. Every day, you pour new water in by attracting new customers. This is your marketing and sales effort. Now, imagine the bucket has a few small holes in the bottom. As you pour water in, some of it is constantly leaking out. These leaks are attrition. Attrition is the natural, and sometimes unnatural, loss of customers over time. The customer who moves to another town, the subscriber who cancels their service, the client who switches to a competitor—they are all part of the attrition “leak.” A business with low attrition is like a bucket with only a few tiny pinpricks. It holds onto its water (customers and revenue) effectively. Most of the effort spent pouring new water in leads to a higher water level. A business with high attrition is like a bucket riddled with large holes. You can pour water in all day long—spending a fortune on advertising and promotions—but you're fighting a losing battle. You're stuck on a “customer acquisition treadmill,” running frantically just to stay in the same place. In the business world, this is most commonly referred to as customer churn or subscriber churn. While companies also experience employee attrition (the rate at which employees leave), as investors, our primary focus is on customer attrition. Why? Because loyal, paying customers are the ultimate source of the sustainable cash flows that determine a company's long-term intrinsic value.

“The single most important decision in evaluating a business is pricing power. If you’ve got the power to raise prices without losing business to a competitor, you’ve got a very good business. And if you have to have a prayer session before raising the price by 10 percent, then you’ve got a terrible business.” - Warren Buffett
¹⁾

For a value investor, analyzing attrition isn't just another box to tick; it's a fundamental part of the investment process. It cuts to the very heart of what makes a business great. A high attrition rate is a massive red flag, while a low one is a glowing green light for several key reasons. 1. Attrition is a “Moat” Detector A company's economic_moat is its sustainable competitive advantage—the invisible wall that protects it from competitors. Attrition is one of the best ways to see if that wall is strong or crumbling.

• Low Attrition Suggests a Wide Moat: Why do customers stay? Perhaps the cost of switching to a competitor is too high (like moving your company's entire accounting system). Perhaps the company has a beloved brand (like Apple or Coca-Cola). Perhaps its product benefits from a network effect (like Facebook or Visa). These are all signs of a powerful moat, and low, stable attrition is the evidence.
• High Attrition Suggests a Weak or No Moat: If customers are leaving in droves, it means there is little to no friction in switching to a competitor. The business is likely competing on price alone, a brutal and often value-destroying strategy.

2. It Reveals the Predictability of Future Cash Flows The core of value investing is estimating a company's future cash flows and buying it for a price well below that estimated value (the margin_of_safety).

• A business with low attrition, like a utility or a dominant software-as-a-service (SaaS) company, has highly predictable, recurring revenue. This makes forecasting future cash flows far more reliable.
• A business with high attrition is a black box. Its future revenues depend on a constant, and uncertain, ability to acquire new customers to replace the ones it loses. This makes any discounted_cash_flow valuation little more than a wild guess.

3. It Exposes the “Customer Acquisition Treadmill” It is almost universally true that it costs significantly more to acquire a new customer than to retain an existing one.

• A high-attrition business must pour enormous amounts of capital into sales and marketing just to replace lost revenue. This capital could otherwise be used for more productive purposes, such as research and development, paying down debt, buying back shares, or issuing dividends. This constant spending acts as a permanent drag on profitability and return_on_invested_capital.
• A low-attrition business enjoys a powerful economic advantage. Its marketing budget can be focused on growth, not just replacement, leading to highly efficient and profitable expansion.

4. It is a Proxy for Management Quality Competent managers understand that a happy customer is a loyal customer. They focus on product quality, excellent customer service, and building long-term relationships. A consistently low or declining attrition rate is often a sign of a management team that is focused on the right things—creating genuine, lasting value for its customers, which in turn creates value for shareholders.

Unlike a simple financial ratio like the P/E ratio, attrition isn't always clearly stated on the front page of a financial report. Analyzing it requires some detective work.

1. 1. Find the Data: Your primary sources will be company filings and presentations. Look in:
   • Annual Reports (10-K): Use “Ctrl+F” to search for terms like “churn,” “attrition,” “retention rate,” “subscriber count,” or “net revenue retention.” Companies in subscription-based industries (telecom, SaaS, media) are more likely to disclose this.
   • Investor Presentations: Management often uses these presentations to highlight positive trends. If the attrition rate is low and falling, they will likely boast about it here.
   • Quarterly Earnings Calls: Listen to the Q&A section. Sharp-witted analysts will often ask management directly about customer retention if the company doesn't disclose it voluntarily.
2. 2. Note the Definition: Be careful. There is no single, legally mandated way to calculate churn. One company might count a customer as “churned” after 30 days of non-payment, another after 90 days. Always read the footnotes to understand how management is defining the metric. The key is to ensure the definition is consistent over time for your trend analysis.
3. 3. Analyze the Trend, Not the Snapshot: A single number is almost useless. The real insight comes from the trend. Is the attrition rate stable at a low level? Is it slowly ticking down (a fantastic sign)? Or is it starting to creep up (a major warning sign)? Track it over at least 3-5 years if possible.
4. 4. Benchmark Against Competitors: Context is everything. A 15% annual churn rate might be catastrophic for an enterprise software company but excellent for a mobile phone provider in a highly competitive market. You must compare a company's attrition rate to its closest rivals. The company with the lowest and most stable churn in its industry is often the one with the strongest competitive position.

So you've found the number. What does it mean?

• A “Good” vs. “Bad” Number: This is entirely industry-dependent.
  • Excellent (often below 5% annually): Typically found in businesses with very high switching costs, like mission-critical enterprise software (e.g., Oracle, SAP) or companies with strong network effects.
  • Good (5% - 15% annually): Common in sticky consumer subscription businesses or well-run B2B services.
  • Concerning (15% - 30% annually): Often seen in highly competitive consumer-facing industries like telecommunications or streaming services. Requires a very efficient customer acquisition engine to survive.
  • Red Flag (above 30% annually): Suggests a broken business model with little to no customer loyalty. The company is on a treadmill to oblivion.
• The Ultimate Red Flag: The biggest red flag of all is when a subscription-based company refuses to disclose its churn rate. This often means the number is unflatteringly high, and management is trying to hide a fundamental weakness in the business.

Let's compare two hypothetical software companies to see how attrition analysis can lead to a clear investment conclusion.

This example shows that looking past the headline “growth” number to the underlying attrition rate gives you a profoundly different—and more accurate—picture of the two businesses.

• A Leading Indicator: Attrition rates can signal trouble long before it becomes obvious in top-line revenue or profit figures. A rising churn rate is an early warning system for a deteriorating competitive position.
• Clarity on Moat Strength: It is one of the best quantitative measures of an economic_moat. It turns an abstract concept into a hard number that can be tracked and compared.
• Focus on Business Quality: Analyzing attrition forces an investor to think like a business owner, focusing on customer satisfaction and long-term durability rather than short-term market sentiment.

• Lack of Disclosure: Many companies, especially those without a subscription model, do not and cannot report a clear attrition number. You may have to look for proxies, like trends in marketing spend as a percentage of revenue.
• Inconsistent Calculations: As mentioned, companies can define and calculate churn differently, making direct comparisons between competitors tricky. Always check the methodology.
• Can Be Misleading in Isolation: A company might have high attrition but also an extremely low and profitable customer acquisition cost (CAC). In some rare cases, this model can work. Attrition should always be analyzed alongside other key metrics.

• economic_moat
• switching_costs
• recurring_revenue
• customer_acquisition_cost
• margin_of_safety
• management_quality
• return_on_invested_capital