stop-loss_order [CapiPedia]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Stop-Loss Order ======
A Stop-Loss Order is an instruction you give your [[broker]] to sell a security when it drops to a specific price, known as the [[stop price]]. Think of it as an automatic panic button, designed to limit your loss on a stock that's heading south. For instance, if you buy a stock at $50, you might place a stop-loss order at $45. Should the stock’s price fall to $45, your order is triggered and immediately becomes a [[market order]] to sell at the best available price. The primary appeal is discipline; it removes emotion from the decision to sell during a downturn. While popular among short-term traders who focus on price charts and momentum, the stop-loss order is a highly controversial tool for the long-term value investor. Its focus on stock price fluctuations rather than the underlying business's health often conflicts with the core principles of buying and holding great companies.
===== How Does It Work? =====
The mechanics are simple, but the devil is in the details. When the market price of your stock hits your stop price, your broker doesn't guarantee you'll sell //at// that price. Instead, your stop-loss order transforms into a market order, which is then executed at the next available price. In a stable market, this might be very close to your stop price. However, in a volatile, fast-dropping market or during an overnight [[gap down]], the [[execution price]] could be significantly lower.
==== Sell-Stop Order ====
This is the classic and most common type. It’s used to protect a [[long position]] (a stock you own).
  * **Example**: You buy shares of "Captain Cookie Co." at $100 per share. You're happy with the business but nervous about short-term market jitters. You set a sell-stop order at $90. If the stock tumbles and a trade occurs at or below $90, your stop order is triggered, and your shares are sold at the prevailing market price. This could be $90, $89.50, or even lower if the price is falling rapidly.
==== Buy-Stop Order ====
This is a tool for those betting //against// a stock, known as [[short seller]]s. A short seller profits when a stock's price falls. A buy-stop order is used to cap their losses if the stock unexpectedly rallies.
  * **Example**: A short seller borrows and sells "Captain Cookie Co." at $100, hoping to buy it back cheaper. To protect against a surge in price, they might place a buy-stop order at $110. If the stock climbs to $110, the order triggers to buy the stock back and close the position, limiting their loss to roughly $10 per share.
===== The Allure and The Pitfalls for a Value Investor =====
For many, the stop-loss feels like a non-negotiable safety feature. But for a value investor, it can be a self-destructive trap that confuses price with value.
==== The Perceived Safety Net ====
The main argument for stop-loss orders is that they enforce discipline and manage [[risk]]. By setting a predetermined exit point, an investor can theoretically prevent a small loss from snowballing into a catastrophic one. It acts as an unemotional circuit breaker, saving you from the paralysis or denial that can set in when a beloved stock takes a nosedive. It automates the decision to "cut your losses," a mantra often repeated in trading circles.
==== The Value Investing Counterargument ====
Value investors see the world differently. Their focus is on a business's long-term [[intrinsic value]], not its daily price wiggles. From this perspective, a stop-loss order is deeply flawed.
  * **Selling Low is a Feature, Not a Bug**: A stop-loss order //forces// you to sell after a stock has already fallen. It crystallizes a paper loss into a permanent one. This is the exact opposite of the value investing goal to "be greedy when others are fearful," as [[Warren Buffett]] advises. A price drop in a fundamentally sound company is a buying opportunity, not a signal to run for the hills.
  * **Volatility is Not Risk**: [[Volatility]], the up-and-down movement of a stock price, is not the same as the risk of a permanent loss of capital. A stop-loss order treats them as the same thing. A great business can have a volatile stock price for many reasons—a market panic, a temporary industry headwind, or a misleading news report. A stop-loss order makes no distinction and sells anyway.
  * **Getting Whipsawed**: Markets are messy. A stock can briefly dip, trigger your stop-loss, and then rocket back up, leaving you on the sidelines. This painful experience, known as being "[[whipsawed]]," means you sold at the bottom for no good fundamental reason and missed out on the recovery.
===== Alternatives to Stop-Loss Orders =====
So, how does a value investor manage risk without a stop-loss? By using smarter, business-focused tools.
  * **Mental Stops and Price Alerts**: Instead of an automatic sell order, set a price alert. If a stock you own drops by, say, 20%, the alert prompts you to //re-evaluate your thesis//, not to sell blindly. Ask yourself: Has the business fundamentally changed for the worse? Was my original analysis wrong? Or is the market just panicking? This approach keeps you in control.
  * **True [[Diversification]]**: The most effective way to protect your overall portfolio is not by setting individual tripwires but by owning a sensible mix of different, uncorrelated assets. Proper diversification ensures that a disaster in one stock doesn't sink your entire ship.
  * **The [[Margin of Safety]]**: This is the value investor's ultimate form of risk management. By only buying a stock for significantly less than your estimate of its intrinsic value, you create a buffer. This margin of safety is your protection against bad luck, errors in judgment, and market downturns. It’s the "ounce of prevention" that’s worth a pound of cure.