Shiller P/E [CapiPedia]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
======Shiller P/E======
Shiller P/E (also known as the [[Cyclically Adjusted Price-to-Earnings ratio]], [[CAPE ratio]], or [[P/E 10 ratio]]) is a valuation metric used to assess whether a stock, or the market as a whole, is overvalued or undervalued. It's a more sophisticated cousin of the standard [[P/E ratio]]. Instead of using just one year of earnings (which can be wildly erratic), the Shiller P/E uses the average of the last 10 years of inflation-adjusted earnings. This clever tweak, developed by [[Nobel laureate]] [[Robert Shiller]], smooths out the short-term bumps and dips caused by the [[business cycle]]. The goal is to get a clearer, more stable picture of a company's or market's "normalized" earning power. By looking at a full decade of performance, investors can better judge if the current price is a fair reflection of long-term potential or just a reaction to a temporary economic boom or bust.
===== Why Smooth Out Earnings? =====
Imagine trying to judge a marathon runner's endurance based on a single, 100-meter sprint. It wouldn't tell you much, right? The standard P/E ratio can be similarly misleading. Corporate earnings can swing dramatically from year to year. During an economic boom, profits soar, making stocks look deceptively cheap on a simple P/E basis. Conversely, during a [[recession]], earnings plummet, making the very same stocks look frighteningly expensive.
This volatility can trick investors into buying high and selling low. The Shiller P/E was designed to solve this problem. By averaging a full decade of real (inflation-adjusted) earnings, it includes profits from both good times and bad. This provides a far more stable and reliable baseline for valuation, helping you see past the short-term economic noise.
===== How the Shiller P/E Works =====
==== The Calculation ====
While the name might sound academic, the concept is straightforward. Think of it as a four-step recipe:
  - **Step 1:** Gather the company's or market's reported earnings per share for each of the last 10 years.
  - **Step 2:** Adjust each of those 10 years of earnings for inflation, typically using an index like the [[Consumer Price Index (CPI)]]. This puts all the earnings figures into today's dollars, making them comparable.
  - **Step 3:** Calculate a simple average of these 10 inflation-adjusted earnings figures. This is your "normalized" earnings number.
  - **Step 4:** Divide the current stock price (or market index level, like the [[S&P 500]]) by this 10-year average earnings figure.
The formula is: **Shiller P/E = Current Real Price / Average of Past 10 Years' Real Earnings**
==== The Result: A Long-Term View ====
The final number gives you a valuation ratio that is anchored in a decade of actual performance, not just the latest quarter's hype or panic. It forces a long-term perspective, which is the bedrock of [[value investing]]. It helps you answer a more meaningful question: "Am I paying a reasonable price relative to what this business has proven it can earn over an entire economic cycle?"
===== Practical Application for Value Investors =====
==== Gauging Market Temperature ====
The Shiller P/E has been a remarkably effective tool for gauging the overall "temperature" of the stock market. It's not a short-term timing tool—it won't tell you when to sell next week—but it provides powerful clues about potential long-term returns.
  * **High Shiller P/E:** A historically high reading (e.g., above its long-term average, say 25 or higher for the S&P 500) suggests the market is expensive. This condition, which Robert Shiller famously dubbed //[[irrational exuberance]]//, has often been followed by years of low or even negative returns.
  * **Low Shiller P/E:** A historically low reading (e.g., below 15) suggests the market is cheap. These have often been fantastic entry points for long-term investors, preceding periods of strong returns.
Think of it as a long-range weather forecast. It doesn't tell you if it will rain tomorrow, but it gives you a good idea of what climate to expect over the next season.
==== Criticisms and Considerations ====
The Shiller P/E is powerful, but it's not a perfect crystal ball. Critics and savvy investors keep a few key points in mind:
  * **Changing Accounting Rules:** The way companies report earnings has changed over time. For example, rules around accounting for [[goodwill]] have evolved, potentially making today's earnings look different from those 30 years ago. This can make direct historical comparisons tricky.
  * **The Interest Rate Environment:** Persistently low [[interest rates]] can make stocks more attractive relative to bonds, potentially justifying a higher-than-average Shiller P/E. If safe assets pay almost nothing, investors are logically willing to pay more for assets with higher potential returns.
  * **Structural Economic Shifts:** Some argue that the modern economy, with its global reach and dominant tech sector, is fundamentally different. Corporate payout policies have also shifted, with many firms favoring [[stock buybacks]] over [[dividends]], which can affect earnings per share and, by extension, the P/E ratio. These factors might mean that the "normal" range for the Shiller P/E has shifted higher.
  * **It's Not a Timing Tool:** This is the most important caveat. A market can remain "expensive" according to the Shiller P/E for many years, and an investor who sells based solely on a high reading might miss out on significant gains. It indicates probabilities, not certainties.