Market Making is the business of standing ready to both buy and sell a financial asset on a continuous basis, thereby providing liquidity to the market. Think of a market maker as a specialized merchant in the stock market bazaar. While you might want to buy or sell a particular stock only occasionally, the market maker is always there, quoting a price at which they will buy from you (the 'bid' price) and a price at which they will sell to you (the 'ask' price). These entities—typically large banks, brokerages, or specialized high-frequency trading firms—are the essential grease in the gears of financial markets. Without them, finding a counterparty for your trade could be a slow and frustrating process, like trying to sell your house on a day when no buyers show up. Their presence ensures that trading is fluid and efficient, allowing investors to enter and exit positions with ease.
The lifeblood of a market maker is the bid-ask spread. This is the small difference between their buying price (bid) and their selling price (ask). It's their reward for taking on the risk of holding the asset and providing the service of immediate liquidity. Imagine a market maker for “Capipedia Corp.” stock. They might display the following quote:
The difference, $0.05, is the spread. If the market maker successfully buys 100 shares at $10.00 from one investor and immediately sells them at $10.05 to another, they earn a profit of 100 shares x $0.05/share = $5.00. This might seem small, but market makers execute millions of such trades daily. It’s a classic high-volume, low-margin business, where profits are built from countless tiny cuts rather than a few big wins. On major exchanges like the New York Stock Exchange, certain firms are appointed as Designated Market Makers (DMMs) for specific stocks, with an obligation to maintain a fair and orderly market.
Being a market maker isn't a license to print money. It comes with two significant risks:
Market makers must hold an inventory of the securities they trade to fulfill orders. This exposes them to price risk. If they buy shares at $10.00 and the stock's price suddenly plummets to $9.50 due to bad news before they can offload them, they lose money. Their goal is to keep their inventory balanced and turn it over as quickly as possible, but in volatile markets, holding even a small position for a few seconds can be perilous.
This is the boogeyman for market makers. Adverse selection is the risk of trading with someone who has superior information. Suppose a corporate insider knows their company is about to announce a disastrous earnings report. They will rush to sell their shares. Who will they sell to? The market maker, who is obligated to quote a bid price. The market maker buys the shares, completely unaware that they are about to become less valuable. To protect themselves from being the “uninformed” party in a trade, market makers will widen their bid-ask spreads during times of high uncertainty or volatility, effectively charging a higher premium for the risk they're taking.
While you may never be a market maker, understanding their role is crucial for navigating the market effectively. For a value investor, the insights are practical and can help improve investment returns.
The bid-ask spread is a direct transaction cost. For a heavily traded, large-company stock, the spread might be just a penny, which is almost negligible. However, for the kind of overlooked small-cap stocks that value investors often hunt for, the spread can be much wider. A spread of 1-2% is not uncommon. This means the moment you buy the stock, you are already down 1-2%. You must overcome this “spread cost” before you can even begin to make a profit. This cost should be mentally factored into your margin of safety. A wider spread signals lower liquidity, meaning it can be harder to buy or sell a large position without affecting the stock's price.
Knowing that market makers profit from the spread and react to order flow should change how you place trades.
Ultimately, the market maker's world is a fast-paced, short-term game. As a value investor, your edge lies in playing a different game entirely—one based on long-term business fundamentals, not split-second price movements. By understanding the structure of the market, you can avoid its pitfalls and execute your long-term strategy more intelligently.